Skip to content

Guitar Tab Books article

Common Guitar Tab Books Mistakes to Avoid

Buying the wrong book, ignoring the rhythm notation, or not listening first — the mistakes guitarists make with tab publications are consistent, and consistently avoidable.

Common Guitar Tab Books Mistakes to Avoid

Tab notation is the most accessible way to learn guitar repertoire, but the way most players buy and use guitar tab books leads to wasted money, slow progress, or both. The mistakes are consistent: buying on impulse before checking accuracy, using the book without listening to the recording, and treating tab as a complete substitute for musical understanding. Each of these is avoidable with a small change in approach.

Buying Without Checking Accuracy First

Accuracy varies enormously across publishers. Unofficial transcriptions — books not licensed by the artist or their publisher — frequently contain errors in fret positions, chord voicings and missing sections. Learning a riff from an inaccurate transcription takes longer to unlearn than it took to learn in the first place. Before buying, check user reviews on music retailers such as Thomann, Andertons or Amazon, specifically filtering for comments on transcription accuracy. Official licensee publications (Hal Leonard, Music Sales, Alfred) are generally more accurate than third-party compilations for the same material.

Ignoring the Rhythm Notation

Tab alone shows where to put your fingers, not how long to hold each note. Most quality publications print standard notation above the tab staff, with note duration symbols giving the rhythmic values. Players who ignore this notation and rely only on their memory of the recording end up guessing at rhythms — which works for songs they know extremely well, but produces imprecise playing for anything less familiar. Reading the note duration values above the tab staff (even without reading full standard notation) significantly improves rhythmic accuracy.

Buying a Full Book for One or Two Songs

Artist songbooks typically cost £15–£30 and contain twenty to forty songs. Buying a physical book to learn two or three songs from it is poor value — particularly when individual song transcriptions are available digitally at £3–£6 each. Before purchasing a complete songbook, confirm how many songs in it you actually intend to learn. If the answer is fewer than five or six, a digital individual download is the more sensible format. This also applies to genre compilations: check the full contents list before buying rather than relying on the title alone.

Not Listening Before Playing

Tab reads better when you already know how the music sounds. Many players open a new book and try to work out the song from tab alone — which is hard, especially for rhythmically complex or ornamented playing. Listening to the recording (or a cover performance) before opening the book gives context for every embellishment mark (bends, slides, hammer-ons) that tab notation cannot fully represent. For unfamiliar songs, three or four careful listens before attempting to play from the tab reduces the total learning time considerably.

Assuming All Tab Books Cover the Same Material

The category of guitar publications includes artist songbooks, method books, technique books and genre compilations. Each has a different purpose. Buying an artist songbook when you need a systematic method to improve technique is a common mismatch — and vice versa. Before purchasing, confirm that the format of the book matches your actual goal: building skill level, learning specific songs, or developing a particular technique. Our guide to guitar tab books explains the difference between formats in detail.

Buying at the Wrong Level

Most guitar tab books are not graded by difficulty; they transcribe the songs as played, which may include techniques beyond the buyer's current level. A beginner buying a complete Jimi Hendrix transcription encounters heavy use of bends, vibrato, whammy bar techniques and fast pentatonic runs — all in the first few pages. The result is discouragement rather than learning. Before buying, check online previews (most retailers show a sample page or two) and assess whether the techniques required match your current abilities. Method books are graded by design and are a more appropriate format for players working at a specific level.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are cheap guitar tab books worth buying?

Cheap unofficial transcriptions are a poor investment if accuracy matters. A £5 third-party compilation may contain incorrect chord voicings, missing sections, or wrong fret positions throughout — learning from bad tab produces habits that take longer to correct than if you had learned nothing. Spend more on officially licensed publications from Hal Leonard or Music Sales, or use well-reviewed individual digital downloads from established retailers.

Can I learn to read tab without learning standard notation?

Yes — and most guitarists do. Tab is self-contained enough for learning songs and technique. The limitation is that tab alone does not communicate rhythm. Players who want to transcribe music themselves, play with musicians who use standard notation (orchestras, session work, formal teaching environments), or progress through graded examinations will find standard notation useful. For the majority of guitarists, tab alone is entirely sufficient for their goals.

How do I know if a tab book is the correct difficulty for me?

Most retailers show a sample page or two in the product listing — use this to assess the techniques required. Look for the most demanding passage in the sample: if it requires techniques you do not yet have (complex bends, sweep picking, advanced fingerstyle patterns), the book will frustrate rather than develop you. For structured progression, method books (Hal Leonard, Alfred) are graded by design and include a stated level on the cover.

Is it better to buy physical tab books or digital downloads?

Physical books are more practical at the music stand, easier to annotate, and more resilient in a practice context. Digital downloads are cheaper, immediately available, and practical when you only need one or two songs from a larger collection. For a complete songbook you intend to work through systematically, the physical format is generally preferable. For single songs or occasional reference, digital is the better value.

Why does my playing sound wrong even when I follow the tab correctly?

Tab shows fret positions but cannot fully represent timing, articulation, dynamics or vibrato — the elements that make a performance sound like the recording. If the notes are correct but the playing sounds wrong, listen more carefully to the recording for rhythmic nuance and listen specifically to how bends, slides and hammer-ons are timed. Watching a performance video of the song alongside the tab is often more informative than reading the tab alone.

Should I always listen to a recording before learning from tab?

Yes — this is one of the most effective things you can do to improve how quickly tab translates into performance. Tab does not convey rhythm, timing, feel or ornamentation with complete precision. Knowing how the music sounds before opening the book means every marking in the tab is contextualised. Three or four close listens before playing from the tab consistently reduces total learning time, particularly for songs with rhythmically complex or ornate playing.

About Rebecca Turner

Rebecca grew up in Birmingham, the city that gave the world heavy metal, and fell for loud guitars early listening to the bands her older brother left lying around. She's spent years untangling the gear behind the riffs — the amps, pedals and pickups that make a sound heavy. She writes about rock and metal guitar with the enthusiasm of a genuine fan.

Comments

Leave a comment

Comments are read before they appear. Links cannot be published.

Your rating (optional)