Essential Sea Shanty Albums Explained

Sea shanty albums are a slightly odd category, and it's worth saying so up front: this music started life as an oral, on-the-job tradition, not something anyone expected to sell on a record. That's exactly what makes the handful of genuinely essential sea shanty albums worth your time — each one solves the same problem differently: how do you put a work song, built for a moving deck and a dozen voices, onto a fixed recording that still feels alive?

Between Wind and Water — The Longest Johns (2018)

This is the record to start with, and not just because of hindsight. The British vocal group recorded their version of "Wellerman" on this 2018 album, three years before the rest of the world caught up with it. What makes it work as a proper listen, rather than a novelty, is the arrangement: several voices trading lead and response the way an actual crew would have, without over-polishing away the rough, communal edges that make a shanty a shanty in the first place. When Decca signed the group in January 2021, it was this album's worth of groundwork that justified the deal.

Fisherman's Friends — Self-Titled Debut (2010)

Long before any of this was a TikTok story, ten fishermen and lifeboat volunteers from Port Isaac in Cornwall had been singing traditional shanties on the harbour for tourists, for decades, purely for the love of it. Their signing to Universal Music in 2010 was reported at the time as one of the more unlikely major-label deals in British pop history, and their self-titled debut album turned that unlikeliness into a genuine UK chart hit. Their story later became a 2019 feature film, which is a fairly rare honour for a group whose day jobs were fishing and crewing lifeboats, not touring.

What earns this album a place on any serious list is authenticity rather than novelty: these were working men singing songs their community had always sung, recorded roughly as they'd always sound down at the harbour.

Nathan Evans and the Post-"Wellerman" Recordings

Nathan Evans's viral 2021 version of "Soon May the Wellerman Come" isn't a full album, but it opened the door for a short run of studio recordings for Polydor that reworked traditional shanties with modern production behind them. Worth remembering as you listen: "Wellerman" itself is a nineteenth-century New Zealand whaling ballad rather than a strict work shanty, so treat these recordings as an entry point into the wider genre rather than the genre's purest example. For the purest example, see the album above.

The Archives That Aren't Quite "Albums"

Some of the most important sea shanty recordings were never packaged as albums at all. American folklorists spent the 1930s and 1940s recording retired seamen, and those field recordings now sit in institutional collections such as the Library of Congress and the English Folk Dance and Song Society. They're not polished listening in the way a commercial release is, but if you want to hear the tradition before anyone thought to arrange it for an audience, these archives are the genuine source material behind everything else on this list. For the fuller story of how we got from those decks to today's records, our sea shanty history piece covers the whole arc.

What to Listen For

Before you go hunting for more sea shanty albums yourself, it helps to know what separates a genuinely good one from a cash-in:

• Real call and response — multiple voices trading lines, not one singer double-tracked to sound like a crowd.
• A mix of shanty types — short-haul, halyard and capstan songs sit at different tempos; an album that only offers one speed is only showing you one corner of the genre. Our piece on sea shanty subgenres explains the differences properly.
• Restraint in production — a light touch of guitar, concertina or fiddle is traditional; wall-to-wall studio polish usually isn't.
• Honest liner notes — the best releases are upfront about which songs are traditional, which are adapted, and which, like "Wellerman", sit slightly outside the strict definition of a work shanty.

Where to Go From Here

If albums feel like too big a commitment before you know the genre, our list of essential individual songs is a gentler way in, and our beginner's guide explains the basics from scratch. If you'd rather know who's actually singing on these records, our rundown of sea shanty artists fills in the names behind the albums above.

Between a scrappy 2018 folk record, a heart-warming Cornish fishing crew, a viral single and a stack of dusty field recordings, that's the real, if slightly unlikely, family of essential sea shanty albums — proof that a genre built for hauling rope has aged rather well on record.

Frequently Asked Questions