Guitar Picks roundup
Guitar Picks: A Complete Buyer's Guide
Guitar picks cost almost nothing, but choosing the wrong thickness or material has a real impact on how you play. Here's how to make a deliberate choice.
Guitar picks cost almost nothing, which makes the question of "which one to buy" feel deceptively simple. In practice, the choice of material, thickness, and shape has a genuine impact on how you play — and buying the wrong ones means either fighting your technique or tolerating a tone that doesn't match what you're after. This guide cuts through the variables so you can make a deliberate choice rather than just grabbing the cheapest pack on the shelf.
Match Thickness to Your Playing Style First
Thickness is the single most important variable, and it's directly tied to how you play:
- Thin (under 0.6 mm): For strummers. The flexibility gives a forgiving feel across chord changes, adds brightness to acoustic strumming, and reduces wrist fatigue on long playing sessions. Not ideal for lead — the flex makes precision difficult.
- Medium (0.73–0.88 mm): The default for most guitarists. Works across styles, doesn't fight you on either strumming or single-note runs. If you're not sure what you want, start here.
- Heavy (1.0–1.2 mm): For players who need precision on lead lines and want the pick to transfer energy directly rather than absorbing some of it. Produces a fuller, warmer tone on most instruments.
- Extra heavy (1.5 mm+): Jazz, bass guitar, and players who want maximum control and minimum flex. Minimal feel of the pick "giving" under the strings.
Before buying in bulk, buy a single pack that spans the range (many brands sell sampler packs). Play the same passage at the same volume on the same guitar with each — the differences in feel will be immediately obvious.
Material: What to Prioritise
Different materials produce different tonal characters and grip properties. The main distinctions:
| Material | Tone Character | Feel / Grip | Durability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Celluloid | Warm, vintage | Smooth, moderate grip | Moderate |
| Nylon | Warm, slightly muted | Smooth, low grip | Good |
| Tortex (Delrin) | Bright, defined | Matte, good grip | Very good |
| Ultem | Bright, crisp | Smooth, low grip | Excellent |
| Metal | Very bright, percussive | Firm, low flex | Very durable |
For most players, the choice is between celluloid, Tortex, or Ultem. Celluloid is the classic — warm and widely available. Tortex grips better and sounds brighter. Ultem (used in D'Addario's Cortex range) offers a premium feel at a modest premium price.
Shape: Standard vs Specialist
The 351 shape — rounded teardrop — is what comes to mind when most people say "guitar pick." It's the default for good reason: it fits naturally in most hand sizes, presents a consistent tip for strumming, and works across styles. When should you consider alternatives?
- Jazz III: If you primarily play lead and want more tip precision. The smaller body and sharper point give improved control at higher speeds. Expect an adjustment period of a few weeks.
- Triangle / tri-tip: Three usable edges mean you rotate when one wears. Good for heavy players who go through picks quickly.
- Thumb pick: If you want to fingerpick with tone-consistent picking for bass strings. Staple of country and bluegrass technique.
Grip: An Underrated Variable
A pick that slips from your fingers in the middle of a song is worse than a pick that sounds slightly off. If you tend to grip loosely or sweat on stage, prioritise picks with a grip surface. Dunlop's Max-Grip range adds a textured hold area; Tortex's matte surface naturally grips better than smooth celluloid. Some players add a small piece of grip tape or rough up a smooth pick with fine sandpaper — both work.
The Price Question
Guitar picks are inexpensive enough that price is rarely a meaningful constraint. A pack of Dunlop Tortex 0.73 mm in ten or twelve picks costs a few pounds; even the premium options (Blue Chip, boutique picks) run to £3–£10 per pick, which is only significant if you lose them constantly. The sensible approach is to spend a few pounds on a sampler assortment across materials and thicknesses and identify what works for you before committing to a larger quantity.
The picks worth splurging on are those you intend to keep long-term — a Blue Chip or Ultem pick worn smooth through months of heavy use genuinely changes how it plays (in a good way), and players often find a particular pick they use for years.
What to Avoid
The most common buying mistake with guitar picks is buying by aesthetics or brand loyalty rather than trying different thicknesses. A pick that matches your guitar's headstock colour does nothing for your playing if the thickness is wrong. Similarly, if you've always used whatever came free with a guitar purchase, there's a good chance you've never actually chosen — and the experience of deliberately trying a thicker or thinner option can be a genuine revelation. The common mistakes guide covers these traps in more detail.
For a broader understanding of what's in the category before you buy, the full explainer walks through every type and feature in detail.
The Bottom Line
When buying guitar picks, prioritise thickness for your playing style, material for tone and grip, and shape for comfort and precision. Buy a sampler first, decide what works, then buy in quantity. The perfect pick is one you stop noticing — it just does what you need it to without requiring any active management.
Comments