P90 Pickups roundup
P90 Pickups: A Complete Buyer's Guide
Buying P90 pickups means navigating everything from budget stock replacements to hand-wound boutique units. This guide covers what to look for, the major manufacturers and how to choose for your guitar and style.
Buying P90 pickups means navigating a range from budget-friendly stock replacements to expensive hand-wound boutique units. Rebecca Turner's guide covers how to evaluate quality, the key manufacturers and how to choose for the guitar and the style.
What to Prioritise When Buying
The key variables in any P90 purchase are: magnet type (Alnico II, III or V, each with different tonal characteristics), output level, wax potting (reduces microphonic feedback in high-gain situations), and whether you need a soapbar or dogear format. Most buyers should establish these basics before comparing brands. Alnico V magnets are brighter and more aggressive; Alnico II are warmer and compress more naturally with playing dynamics; Alnico III offer a middle ground.
Budget Options
For a cost-effective entry into quality aftermarket P90s, Seymour Duncan's SP90-1 (Vintage P-Rails) and DiMarzio's DP169 (Bluesbucker) are well-regarded options at around £80–£100 each. GFS (Guitar Fetish) and Tonerider produce less expensive options in the £30–£60 range that offer a genuine step above stock pickups in entry-level guitars. These are appropriate for players who want to explore P90 character without a large investment and aren't sure yet whether they'll stick with the tone.
Mid-Range: Seymour Duncan and DiMarzio
Seymour Duncan's full range of P90 pickups includes the SP90-1 (vintage output, Alnico V, soapbar and dogear formats) and the SP90-3 (in a humbucker-sized housing for direct swap in humbucker-routed guitars). DiMarzio's Virtual P90 uses a noise-cancelling design that approximates the P90 tone while reducing hum — useful in live situations where hum is a practical problem. These mid-range options suit gigging players who want reliable performance and controlled output without boutique pricing.
Premium: Lollar and Fralin
At the premium end, Lollar Pickups' P90 set is among the most respected in the aftermarket — hand-wound with close attention to vintage specification, available in multiple Alnico grades and offering genuine tonal depth and dynamic response. Lindy Fralin's P92 (a noise-cancelling P90-style pickup) and standard P90 set are similarly hand-wound with a focus on accuracy to vintage tone. These pickups cost £150–£250 per pickup and are aimed at players who have a specific sonic target and the guitar to justify the investment.
Boutique Options
Bare Knuckle Pickups (UK-based) produces several P90-style sets including the Mule and The Pig, each with different character profiles and available in custom winding specifications. Wolfetone (US) and Throbak are other respected boutique winders. At this level, the differences between options are subtle enough that personal taste and specific playing context matter more than brand reputation. Many players at this price point have existing reference pickups they are trying to match or exceed.
Humbucker-Sized P90s
For players with humbucker-routed guitars, several manufacturers produce P90 pickups in a humbucker housing — Seymour Duncan SP90-3, Lollar P90 in humbucker size, DiMarzio Virtual P90 (DP169). These offer genuine P90 character without routing modification. The trade-off varies by manufacturer; some humbucker-sized P90s capture the tone more faithfully than others. Reading reviews from players who have compared them directly to traditional soapbar P90s is worthwhile before purchasing.
Bottom Line
Buying P90 pickups comes down to format, magnet type, output and budget. For most upgrades from stock pickups, Seymour Duncan or Lollar represent the most reliable quality-to-price ratio. For a full picture of what to expect from the tone, the complete P90 guide covers the history and character of the format.
Comments