Common Acoustic and Electric Mistakes to Avoid

I've heard the same handful of regrets from friends over the years, almost always about the decision between acoustic and electric guitars rather than the instrument itself being a dud. Let's go through them properly, so you don't repeat any of them.

Mistake 1: Choosing Purely by Genre Stereotype

"I like rock, so I need electric" skips a much more useful question: how do you actually want to spend your time playing? Plenty of rock guitarists started and stayed happy on acoustic, and plenty of folk and country players lean electric. Let your actual goals guide the choice, not a genre assumption.

Mistake 2: Buying Electric Without Budgeting for an Amp

This one catches people out constantly. An electric guitar on its own, unplugged, is genuinely quiet — you need an amplifier and a cable to hear it properly. If the budget only stretches to the guitar itself, you've bought half an instrument. Sort the amp out at the same time, not as an afterthought.

Mistake 3: Blaming the Instrument for a Bad Setup

A guitar that buzzes, feels stiff, or won't stay in tune is very often a setup problem — action, intonation or neck relief — rather than a fault with acoustic or electric as a category. Before deciding you've bought the "wrong" type, get a proper setup done. It's a cheaper fix than a whole new instrument, and it solves the actual problem.

Mistake 4: Putting the Wrong Strings on the Wrong Guitar

Nylon strings belong on classical guitars, not electrics — magnetic pickups only respond to ferromagnetic metal, so nylon strings simply won't work properly. Steel strings, similarly, aren't designed for a classical nylon-string body. It sounds obvious written down, but it's an easy mix-up for someone new to buying strings themselves.

Mistake 5: Assuming Acoustic-Electric Is Always the Smarter Buy

Built-in electronics are genuinely useful if you actually plan to plug in for gigs or recording. If you don't have a concrete reason to need that yet, you're paying for a feature that sits unused, when a plain acoustic would have done exactly the same job for less.

Mistake 6: Ignoring Body Size and Hand Comfort

A guitar that's genuinely uncomfortable to hold gets played less, full stop — no amount of tonal quality makes up for that. A large dreadnought-style acoustic can feel unwieldy for a smaller player, just as a full-scale electric can feel awkward for younger or smaller hands. Try before you buy wherever you possibly can.

Mistake 7: Expecting the "Easier" Type to Solve Bad Technique

Electrics do often have lighter strings and lower action, which genuinely can make fretting easier — but that's not a substitute for practising properly. Switching instruments to dodge a technique problem usually just brings the same problem along with you, on a different guitar.

Still deciding between the two? Our complete guide explains the real difference properly, and our buyer's guide covers what you'll actually need to budget for. Brand new to guitar? Our beginner's guide is the gentler starting point, and our value round-up shows where the smart spending actually is.

The Bottom Line

Most mistakes people make with acoustic and electric guitars come down to expectation and setup, not the instrument itself. Sort those two things out honestly, and either type will serve you well for years.

Frequently Asked Questions